Is physician anesthesia cost-effective?

UNLABELLED One of the most controversial issues in anesthesia is whether nonmedically directed nurse anesthetists are relatively more cost-effective than anesthesiologists in the provision of anesthesia care. We electronically surveyed anesthesia practices throughout the United States to estimate the range in anesthesia professional costs from the payer perspective. Using this survey data on anesthesia reimbursement and published outcomes studies, we developed an ad hoc model to estimate the cost-effectiveness of physician-directed anesthesia relative to a nonmedically directed nurse anesthetist model of care from the payer perspective. Cost-effectiveness ratios were defined as the ratio of incremental costs associated with physician anesthesia relative to the estimated incremental life expectancy gains with this model of care (i.e., dollars per year of life saved [US dollars /YLS]). Reference case results suggest that physician anesthesia is cost saving with an estimated incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of -US dollars 2601/YLS for a younger privately insured patient and an estimated cost-effectiveness ratio of -US dollars 4410/YLS for an elderly Medicare insured patient. Cost-effectiveness ratios ranged from -US dollars 4410 to US dollars 38778/YLS in univariate and multivariate sensitivity analyses across payer types. Results were most sensitive to assumed differences in reimbursement (commercial conversion factors) and to mortality rate assumptions by provider type. This analysis offers economic evidence in support of the physician anesthesia model of care. IMPLICATIONS Recent outcome studies suggest improved patient outcomes when physicians medically direct nurse anesthetists versus anesthesia care delivered with nonmedically directed nurses. The relative cost-effectiveness of this practice model is, however, unknown. This economic analysis suggests that outcome gains with physician anesthesia may be obtained at cost savings or, under conservative assumptions, at a cost deemed reasonable by society.